Most shoppers have left a store without buying anything because of rush-hour problems. That’s the main finding of a new report from retail workforce software provider Logile, released as retailers head into the holiday stretch from Black Friday through New Year’s.
The Logile 2026 Peak Hour Penalty Report found that 78 percent of shoppers have walked out of a store empty-handed in the past six months because of problems such as long lines or a lack of help. Among shoppers who remembered what they had planned to spend, the average abandoned trip was worth about $113. Logile surveyed 750 U.S. consumers 18 and older in October through the Pollfish survey platform. All respondents shop for groceries and everyday items mostly in person or through a mix of in-store and online shopping.
The survey covered the previous six months, which doesn’t include last year’s holidays. That means the $113 average reflects ordinary shopping weeks.
“Shoppers see a long line at 5 p.m. on a Friday as something a store should have anticipated, and they’re right,” said Purna Mishra, president and CEO of Logile. “Store teams work incredibly hard, but they can’t always overcome disconnected plans, staffing gaps or shelves that weren’t replenished in time.”
Key findings
- Big-basket losses: 43 percent of shoppers walked out on a trip where they had planned to spend $50 or more, including 24 percent who had planned to spend $100 or more.
- Loyalty at stake: 55 percent have stopped treating a store as their regular store or cut back on visits after repeated bad trips.
- Seen as a planning failure: 74 percent say understaffing during a predictable busy time is a planning failure, not bad luck.
- Blame goes to management: 59 percent blame store management or corporate when a store is a mess during a rush, while only 8 percent blame the employees working that shift.
- Top complaint: Long checkout lines were named by 42 percent as the most frustrating part of a short-staffed store, nearly four times the share of any other answer.
- Readiness gaps: 48 percent have found checkout lanes closed in a packed store, and 46 percent have encountered empty shelves during busy periods.
- What shoppers want: 64 percent say more open checkout lanes would improve their experience, 42 percent want better-stocked shelves and 35 percent want more associates on the sales floor.
- Willingness to pay: 52 percent say they would pay extra on a $100 purchase at a store that usually has shorter lines and associates available to help.
Holiday pressure ahead
The holidays will add to the strain. 46 percent of shoppers say longer checkout lines make the period from Black Friday through New Year’s harder than the rest of the year. The survey also found that 60 percent would view a store more favorably if they knew it used technology to keep enough staff scheduled for its busiest times.
Logile said preparing for peak hours requires more than scheduling. Retailers also need to match inventory, replenishment and fresh production to expected demand. Its findings mirror the associate view in its 2025 Labor Planning & Optimization Report, where 77 percent of retail workers said labor planning gaps were hurting store performance.
“The opportunity for retailers is to anticipate demand and connect the decisions that follow, from staffing and scheduling to inventory and store execution,” Mishra said. “That’s how you move from reacting to the rush to being ready for it.”
Founded in 2005, Logile provides AI-powered forecasting, labor scheduling, task execution, inventory, fresh item management and food safety software for retailers.
Related: Vallarta Supermarkets Achieves 1,070% ROI With Logile
